Advocacy Documents

HRC35: Statement on Ukraine – the Impact of Interventions by International Financial Institutions on Women

Document type:
Date/Month:
15 May 2017
Body submitted to:

Written statement to the 35th regular session of the UN Human Rights Council (Geneva, 6 – 23 June 2017)

The lowering of social standards and narrowing of access to social services, arising from the armed conflict and macro-economic reforms, has significantly reduced the quality of life and safety of women in Ukraine. This statement will focus on the impact of macro-economic reforms, an area overlooked by the Human Rights Council (HRC) in its deliberations.

Austerity measures included as part of the conditionalities attached to lending provided by International Financial Institutions (IFIs), mainly the International Monetary Fund (IMF) have disproportionately affected women in Ukraine. WILPF has highlighted these negative impacts in submissions to the CEDAW Committee[1] and to the Universal Periodic Review (UPR).[2] Violations of women’s economic and social rights resulting from implementation of austerity measures has contributed to the feminization of poverty and the deepening of gender inequalities within the family and in the society as a whole.

These violations pose significant obstacles to women’s meaningful participation in Ukraine’s peace efforts. While promoting and protecting women’s economic and social rights are crucial ends in themselves, women also need to have the economic resources to be active participants in decision-making processes. Women will not be able to participate in the peace process and post-conflict reconstruction efforts if they struggle to meet the most basic needs for themselves and their families.

The reduced access to social and economic services, arising from the cost of the armed conflict and strict macro-economic reforms designed through the lending agreement with the IMF run against Ukraine’s obligations to respect, protect, and fulfill economic and social rights, without retrogression and using maximum available resources.

The reduction in public spending has disproportionately affected women in two ways. First, cutbacks in public health and social service expenditures rely on shifting and increasing the burden of care to women. Gendered social norms mean women are expected to compensate for reduced state support by spending more time on unpaid care-work in the family. This, in turn, also reduces the amount of time available for participating in the formal economy. Second, education, health care and social work, public administration, sectors with most job cuts in the economic reform program, are among the most female-dominated economic sectors.

Some of the conditions attached to the provision of IMF funding with significant implications on women are: the de facto elimination of fuel subsidies, which has caused higher prices for gas, heating, electricity and transportation; sweeping spending cuts on areas such as health, education and social services; and a major reform of the pension system.[3]

Impact of the Elimination of Subsidies for Fuel and Heating

Conditionalities, linked to the IMF loan, have required the State to reduce fuel subsidies in order to reduce the deficit of Naftogaz (the state-owned enterprise). Ukraine has failed to provide affordable solutions to its energy crisis and implement its social protection program in connection to the reform.

The consequences of the negotiated IMF conditionalities on reducing fuel subsides fuel has led to higher prices for gas, heating, electricity, transportation and other goods and services related to fuel use. The corresponding increase in tariffs has had an extremely negative impact on the living standards of much of the population. In fact, in a country in which prior to the conflict some 60-80% of households received subsidies to pay for utility bills, energy consumption has decreased by 30% compared to 2011. This reduction is not due to energy efficiency, but results directly from the elimination of fuel subsidies.

The Ukrainian population as a whole has experienced severe impoverishment, leading to a reduction in all consumption that is not related to immediate survival.[4] In rural areas, the negative impact of the elimination of fuel subsidies has been compounded by the increase in the coal price due to Ukraine’s decision to apply the Rotterdam Plus formula to set the wholesale market price for coal.[5] Residents in rural areas rely more on gas boilers, coal and firewood than on central heating. Women are disproportionally impacted as they tend to experience more than both urban women and rural men unemployment and harsh living conditions including because, as a general rule in Ukraine, women earn less than men.

Cuts in the Public Sector

The policy of cutting jobs in the health, education and social services sectors primarily affects women who pre-conflict constituted up to 80% of the total number of employees. Cutting, capping or freezing wages or recruitment in the public sector is one of the most clear-cut ways in which macro-economic policy can undermine gender equality, as such policies disproportionately affect women. While the wages in these sectors are the lowest, women employees have previously benefited from a stable income and guarantees of social protection of workers, including pensions, paid holiday, and maternity leave.

As well as reducing social spending, Ukraine has also reduced the taxation for big businesses, whilst simultaneously increasing the tax burden on end-users, employees, and medium and small businesses. The vast majority of people affected by these changes are women, including because there are more women among small entrepreneurs as compared with men (53% in 2011, according to the World Bank) and, due to a number of constraints, female-headed enterprises are less profitable regardless of the sector of economic activity.[6]

In accordance with IMF requirements, during 2014-2015, 165,000 civil service jobs were cut, with overall plans of a 20% reduction in the civil service workforce. This reduction has been undertaken through, inter alia, the reorganization of ten and closing of eight government agencies. There are plans for further downsizing of the public sector with the goal of lowering the overall spending on salary for civil servants to around 9% of GDP in the medium term. Women comprise more than 75% of the civil service, predominately in non-managerial positions,[7] and, therefore, have been disproportionately impacted – and will continue to be – by these cuts. Again, no effective social protection programs have been developed or implemented to compensate or ensure sustainable job creation for women.

In 2014, 12,000 social workers lost their jobs; many of them were women.[8] These cuts had extremely negative consequences for both the beneficiaries of social services and the women whose jobs were cut, since the vast majority of workers in schools, hospitals and clinics are women. A year later, a further 25,000 healthcare professionals lost their jobs.[9]

In the last three years, decentralization has led to a significant transfer of responsibilities for the financing of education, science and healthcare to local budgets, most of which have very limited financial resources. This has led to a reduction in the number of hospital beds and hospital staff, and in many cases, local government authorities have had to close schools, hospitals and clinics due to the lack of resources. One of the most well-known examples is the closing of the hospital and several schools in the town of Romny, which caused a wave of protests and outrage across the country.

Since 2013, there has been a sharp decline in state spending on education services. This has impacted both the beneficiaries of these services and the employees in this sector, who tend to be mostly women, who are finding it necessary to look for additional part-time jobs to supplement their income. The government plans to reduce workers in the education sector to fulfill the IMF requirement of ‘optimization’ of the network of schools and educational institutions. Spending cuts in the educational sector has led to the closing of several educational facilities. In 2012, there were 20,090 educational institutions in Ukraine. This number has steadily decreased. In particular, between 2014 and 2016, 38 schools were closed in urban areas and 231 in rural areas.[10] This trend is expected to continue; there are now 2,500 schools that are candidates for closure due to their small numbers of pupils (10-100 pupils).[11]

Cuts in Child Benefits

The monthly payments of assistance for childcare until the age of three were de facto abolished in July 2014, as part of the IMF required reforms in the areas of social services. These payments were one of the most effective types of social assistance to families with children. In the case of low-income families and single parents, they helped low-income families and single parents to survive during their time away from the labour market.

Recommendations

IMF and other IFIs do not apply a human-rights-based approach as part of their macroeconomic framework and therefore neglect the consequences of human rights obligations in the negotiations.

WILPF urges States to ensure that HRC address the negative effect of macro-economic reforms on human rights in Ukraine, and in particular on the often disproportionate impact on women. In this regard, the HRC should call on Ukraine to:

  • conduct cumulative and participatory human rights, gender and environmental impact and budget assessments before accepting conditionalities linked to funding from IMF or other IFIs;
  • ensure that these assessments are part of the negotiations with IFIs, and that social protection programs are included in the outcome documents and budget allocations;
  • adopt a rights-based approach to macroeconomic policy-making and spending decisions that affect vulnerable groups, including cumulative and participatory budget and impact assessments;
  • identify and implement policies that can limit the negative impact of austerity measures or provide and effective alternative;
  • ensure that women and civil society are included in the consultations and decision-making around IFI loans, and increase transparency in any negotiation and approval process.

Download the statement as PDF: Ukraine: the Impact of Interventions by International Financial Institutions on Women

Download the statement as a PDF UN Document: Ukraine: the Impact of Interventions by International Financial Institutions on Women

ENDNOTES

[1] “The Effects of Intervention by International Financial Institutions on Women’s Human Rights in Ukraine”, available in English and Ukrainian at: https://www.wilpf.org/wilpf-publications/.

[2]   “Obstacles to Women’s Meaningful Participation in Peace Efforts in Ukraine”, at: https://www.wilpf.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/UKRAINE.UPR_.JointSubmission-30-Mar-2017.pdf.

[3]   For information on the reform of the pension system, see page 13 of the UPR submission and page 8 of the report to CEDAW.

[4]   For more information, see pages 7-9 of the UPR submission.

[5]   See, for example, https://www.kyivpost.com/business/state-faces-off-miners-subsidies-dying-coal-industry.html

[6]   See paragraphs 3.56 and 4.5 in the World Bank’s Country Gender Assessment for Ukraine (2016), available at http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/128891470822320083/pdf/107673-PUB-P156988-ADD-ISBN-PUBLIC-SoltisBookENweb.pdf.

[7]   http://infolight.org.ua/content/derzhavna-sluzhba-v-ukrayini-u-2005-2012-rokah-osnovni-pokazniki-yakisnogo-takilkisnogo-sklad.

[8]   http://zakon4.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/96-2014-п.

[9]   http://www.fpsu.org.ua/nasha-borotba/novini-chlenskikh-organizatsij/6981-skorochennya-merezhi-ta-chiselnostipratsivnikiv-zakladiv-okhoroni-zdorov-ya-e-neprijnyatnim.

[10]  Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine, http://mon.gov.ua/usi-novivni/novini/2016/01/13/zagalnoosvitni-navchalnizakladi-statistika-za-dva-navchalni-roki/.

[11] For more information, see page 12 of the UPR submission.

Share your thoughts and ideas

Not able to join the calls? You can still share your thoughts and ideas ahead of the call, or view the notes and comment on them afterwards!

Share your thoughts and ideas in any of the following ways:

  • Online form (AR, EN, FR, SP)
  • Video or voice message using the WILPF Studio app (Project ID is FUTURE – Get Started Instructions) – your video will not be public. It will only be viewed by WILPF’s Membership team.
  • Email to membership@wilpf.org
  • Voice/Text message via your regional WhatsApp/Signal group (or contact WILPF’s Membership Team if you need the phone numbers).

Développer et renforcer la
manière dont on travaille ensemble

‘Future WILPF’ est bien plus que le Programme International. Il s'agit de renforcer notre mouvement, d'équiper notre communauté mondiale afin qu’elle puisse au mieux agir pour le changement, et s’engager ensemble pour une vision collective d’une paix féministe. Au cours des appels nationaux, régionaux et mondiaux qui auront lieu dans la période précédant le Congrès, nous discuterons des lacunes que nous souhaitons combler, des politiques que nous devons changer ou créer. Nous réfléchirons aussi à comment ajuster au mieux nos manières de faire et processus de travail, et plus encore. Ensemble, nous chercherons des solutions, afin de réaliser notre vision collective pour l’avenir de WILPF.

Coordonné par le Groupe de coordination du développement organisationnel, mais mis en œuvre par l'ensemble de WILPF!
Ouvert

Join or host a consultation

From July 2021 onwards, you will have many opportunities to participate in discussions aimed at developing the vision, values, and actions of Future WILPF. Want to host a discussion? Contact membership@wilpf.org

Volunteer as a translator or interpreter

Do you speak multiple languages? If so, we need you! As we move through the process of developing the next International Programme, we will need help with translations of internal documents and small pieces of text. We will also need help with translations during breakout sessions on regional and global calls. We are primarily looking for individuals able to speak and write in two or more of the following languages: English, French, Spanish, and Arabic. If you are interested in providing your skills, please contact membership@wilpf.org for more information.

Co-create the next International Programme

Have your voice heard! WILPF’s next International Programme will be developed through a process of co-creation – meaning our entire worldwide community is invited to participate in regional, national, and global discussions about what our future should look like. Get involved today to share your thoughts on WILPF’s work, vision, values, and actions.

Start by exploring this page, checking out the Participation Pack, or joining one of the many upcoming discussions. You can also write to your regional representative to hear more about how you can participate on a national and regional level.

Overseen by the International Board.
Open

Organise and attend Congress
2022

WILPF’s next International Congress will take place in 2022, but the exact dates and format are still to be determined due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. We will open this track as soon as we have more information about Congress and how members can participate.

Coordinated by the International Board and the Congress Steering Committee.
Opening soon

Nominate WILPFers to serve
as representatives

Each International Congress includes the election of WILPFers to join the International Board. This board is responsible for the overall leadership of WILPF, for setting the strategic and tactical objectives of the organisation as a whole, and for ensuring that WILPF stays true to its aims, values, and principles.

It is the role of the present International Board to establish a Nomination Committee, while the election process is coordinated by an Election Committee that will be constituted at the beginning of Congress.
Opening Soon

Build and strengthen the way
WILPF works together

Future WILPF is about more than the International Programme. It’s about building the strength and power of our movement, equipping our global community to take action for change, and committing deeply to a collective vision of feminist peace. During the national, regional, and global calls that will take place in the period leading up to Congress and in connection with the development of the International Programme, we will discuss gaps that need to be filled, policies we need to change, policies we need to make, work methods we need to finetune, and more. And we will seek solutions together, so we can fulfill our collective vision for a Future WILPF.

Coordinated by the Organisational Development Coordination Group, but implemented by all of WILPF!
Open

Partage tes pensées et tes idées

Selon tes attentes, quelles sont les 3 fonctions principales de la gouvernance de WILPF?

Rejoins ou anime une discussion

À partir de juillet 2021, les membres de WILPF auront de nombreuses occasions de participer à des discussions visant à développer la vision, les valeurs et les actions de Future WILPF. Tu souhaites animer une discussion ? Contacte membership@wilpf.org

Porte-toi volontaire pour être traductrice ou interprète

Parles-tu plusieurs langues ? Si c’est le cas, nous avons besoin de toi!
Au fur et à mesure que nous progressons dans ce processus, nous allons avoir besoin d’aide pour la traduction de documents internes et de courts texte.
Nous aurons également besoin d’aide pour les traductions lors des sessions en petits groupes pendant les appels régionaux et mondiaux. Nous recherchons principalement des personnes capables de parler et d’écrire dans au moins deux des langues suivantes : anglais, français, espagnol et arabe. Si tu souhaites apporter tes compétences, contactes-nous à membership@wilpf.org pour plus d’informations.

Participer à l'élaboration du
prochain Programme International

Fais entendre ta voix ! Le prochain Programme International de WILPF sera développé grâce à un processus de co-création – ce qui signifie que chaque membre de notre communauté globale est invitée à participer aux discussions régionales, nationales et mondiales au sujet de notre avenir. Impliques-toi dès aujourd'hui en partageant tes réflexions sur le travail, la vision, les valeurs et les actions de la WILPF. Commence par explorer cette page, consulte le pack de participation ou rejoins l'une des nombreuses discussions à venir. Tu peux également écrire à ta représentante régionale pour en savoir plus sur la façon dont tu peux participer aux niveaux national et régional.

Supervisé par le Conseil international.
Open

Organiser Le Congrès 2022
et y participer

Le prochain Congrès International de WILPF aura lieu en 2022, mais les dates exactes et le format restent à déterminer en raison de la pandémie de COVID-19. Nous ouvrirons cette piste dès que nous aurons plus d' informations sur le Congrès et sur la manière dont les membres peuvent y participer.

Coordonné par le Conseil international et le Comité directeur du Congrès.
Ouverture
prochaine

Désigner des représentantes
de WILPF

Chaque Congrès International comprend l'élection de WILPFers au Conseil International. Ce conseil est responsable de la direction générale de WILPF, de la définition des objectifs stratégiques et tactiques de l'organisation dans son ensemble et de la garantie que WILPF reste fidèle à ses objectifs, valeurs et principes.

C'est le rôle du Conseil international actuel que d'établir un Comité de nomination, tandis que le processus d'élection est coordonné par un Comité d'élection qui sera constitué au début du Congrès.
Ouverture
prochaine

Comparte tus pensamientos e ideas

Según tus expectativas, ¿cuales son las 3 funciones principales de la gobernanza de WILPF?

Build and strengthen the way
WILPF works together

المستقبلية هي أكثر من مجرد برنامج دولي. يتعلق الأمر ببناء قوتنا وقوة حركتنا، وتجهيز مجتمعنا العالمي لاتخاذ إجراءات من أجل التغيير، والالتزام برؤيتنا الجماعية للسلام النسوي. خلال المكالمات الوطنية والإقليمية والعالمية التي ستتم في الفترة التي تسبق الكونغرس والتي تتعلق بتطوير البرنامج الدولي، سنناقش الفجوات التي يجب سدها والسياسات التي نحتاج إلى تغييرها والسياسات التي نحتاجها لصنع طرق عمل. وسنسعى معاً إلى إيجاد حلول، حتى نتمكن من تحقيق رؤيتنا الجماعية لمستقبل WILPF.

يشرف على هذه العملية مجموعة تنسيق التطوير التنظيمي، ولكن يتم تنفيذها بمشاركة جميع عضوات WILPF!
مفتوح الآن

Participe en o organiza un debate

A partir de julio de 2021, tendrás muchas oportunidades de participar en los debates destinados a desarrollar la visión, los valores y las acciones de WILPF del futuro. ¿Quieres organizar un debate? Contacta membership@wilpf.org

Contribuye como traductora o intérprete

¿Hablas varios idiomas? Si es así, ¡te necesitamos! A medida que avancemos en el proceso de desarrollo del próximo Programa Internacional, necesitaremos ayuda con la traducción de documentos internos y pequeños textos. También necesitaremos ayuda con las traducciones durante las sesiones de trabajo en las convocatorias regionales y globales. Principalmente buscamos personas capaces de hablar y escribir en dos o más de los siguientes idiomas: inglés, francés, español y árabe. Si estás interesada en aportar sus conocimientos, póngase en contacto con membership@wilpf.org para obtener más información.

Ayuda a crear el próximo
Programa Internacional

Expresate! El próximo Programa Internacional de WILPF se desarrollará a través de un proceso de co-creación - lo que significa que toda nuestra comunidad mundial está invitada a participar en discusiones regionales, nacionales y globales sobre cómo debería ser nuestro futuro. Participa hoy para compartir tus ideas sobre el trabajo, la visión, los valores y las acciones de WILPF. Empieza por explorar esta página, consulta el Kit de Participación o únete a uno de los muchos debates que se plantearán próximamente. También puedes escribir a tu representante regional para saber más sobre cómo puedes participar a nivel nacional y regional.

Start by exploring this page, checking out the Participation Pack, or joining one of the many upcoming discussions. You can also write to your Section or regional representative to hear more about how you can participate on a national and regional level.

Supervisado por el Consejo Internacional.
Abierto

Organiza y asiste el Congreso
de 2022

El próximo Congreso Internacional de WILPF tendrá lugar a partir de julio de 2022; las fechas exactas y el formato están aún por determinar debido a la pandemia de COVID-19 en curso. Abriremos esta vía en cuanto tengamos más información sobre el Congreso y sobre cómo pueden participar las miembros.

Coordinado por el Consejo Internacional y el Comité Directivo del Congreso.
Próxima
apertura

Designe WILPFeras para
servir como representantes

Cada Congreso Internacional incluye la elección de miembros de WILPF para formar parte de la Junta Internacional. Esta junta es responsable de la dirección general de WILPF, de establecer los objetivos estratégicos y tácticos de la organización en su conjunto y de garantizar que WILPF se mantenga fiel a sus objetivos, valores y principios.

Corresponde a la actual Junta Internacional establecer un Comité de Candidaturas, mientras que el proceso de elección es coordinado por un Comité Electoral que se constituirá al inicio del Congreso.
Próxima
apertura

Desarrolla y fortalece las
maneras de trabajar conjuntamente
en WILPF

La WILPF del futuro es algo más que el Programa Internacional. Se trata de construir la fuerza y el poder de nuestro movimiento, de equipar a nuestra comunidad global para que actúe por el cambio y de comprometerse profundamente con una visión colectiva de la paz feminista. Durante las convocatorias nacionales, regionales y mundiales que tendrán lugar en el periodo previo al Congreso y en relación con el desarrollo del Programa Internacional, debatiremos sobre las lagunas que hay que cubrir, las políticas que hay que cambiar, las políticas que hay que construir, los métodos de trabajo que hay que afinar, etc. Y buscaremos soluciones juntas, para poder cumplir con nuestra visión colectiva de una WILPF del Futuro.

Coordinado por el Grupo de Coordinación de Desarrollo Organizativo, pero implementado por toda WILPF.
Abierto

شاركن آرائكن

سؤال الساعة: ما هي مبادئ وقيم الرابطة النسائية الدولية للسلم والحرية التي تشعرين أنها أكثر أهمية بالنسبة لك؟

الانضمام إلى/استضافة حوار أو نقاش

اعتباراً من يوليو ٢٠٢١ فصاعداً، سيكون لديكن العديد من الفرص للمشاركة في المناقشات التي تهدف إلى تطوير رؤية وقيم وأفعال WILPF المستقبلية. في حال رغبة إي منكن في استضافة مناقشة، الرجاء التواصل معنا من خلال: membership@wilpf.org

تطوعن كمترجمات للترجمة اللغوية أو الفورية

إن كانت لديكم المهارات اللغويّة، فنحن بحاجة لكن! بينما نتقدّم في عملية تطوير البرنامج الدولي التالي، سنحتاج إلى المساعدة في ترجمة المستندات الداخلية والنصوص. سنحتاج أيضاً إلى المساعدة في الترجمة أثناء الجلسات الجانبية للمكالمات الإقليمية والعالمية. نحن نبحث بشكل أساسي عن أفراد قادرين على التحدث والكتابة بلغتين أو أكثر من اللغات التالية: الإنجليزية والفرنسية والإسبانية والعربية. من لها اهتمام بتوفير مهاراتها، فيرجى التواصل معنا للحصول على المزيد من المعلومات، على العنوان التالي:
membership@wilpf.org

Co-create the next International Programme

ليكن صوتكِ مسموع! سيتم تطوير برنامج WILPF الدولي التالي من خلال عملية إنشاء مشتركة - مما يعني أن مجتمع WILPF العالمي بأكمله مدعو للمشاركة في المناقشات الإقليمية والوطنية والعالمية حول الشكل الذي يجب أن يتّخذه مستقبلنا. انضموا إلينا وشاركن أفكاركن حول عمل WILPF ورؤيتها وقيمها. ابدأن باستكشاف هذه الصفحة، أو استكشاف رزمة المشاركة، أو الانضمام إلى إحدى المناقشات القادمة. يمكنكن أيضاً الكتابة إلى ممثلتكن الإقليمية، لسماع المزيد حول كيفية المشاركة على المستوى الوطني والإقليمي.

يشرف على هذه العملية مجلس WILPF الدولي.
مفتوح الآن

Organise and attend
Congress 2022

سيعقد كونغرس WILPF الدولي القادم في عام ٢٠٢٢، ولكن لا يزال يتعين تحديد التواريخ والشكل الدقيق بسبب جائحة COVID-19 المستمرة. سنفتح هذا المسار بمجرد حصولنا على مزيد من المعلومات حول الكونغرس وكيف يمكن المشاركة فيه.

يشرف على هذه العملية مجلس WILPF الدولي واللجنة التوجيهية للمؤتمر.
سيفتح قريباً

Nominate WILPFers to serve
as representatives

يتضمن كل مؤتمر دولي انتخاب عضوات للانضمام إلى مجلس WILPF الدولي. هذا المجلس مسؤول عن القيادة العامة لـ WILPF؛ عن تحديد الأهداف الإستراتيجية والتكتيكية للمؤسسة ككل؛ و عن ضمان التزام WILPF بأهدافها وقيمها ومبادئها.

إن دور المجلس الدولي الحالي هو إنشاء لجنة الترشيح، بينما يتم تنسيق عملية الانتخابات من قبل لجنة الانتخابات التي سيتم تشكيلها في بداية كونغرس.
سيفتح قريباً

Share your thoughts and ideas

Question of the moment: What are the top 3 functions you expect from WILPF governance?